Revert streaming codable handler change and propose it as an example instead of an handler API. **Motivation:** I made a mistake when submitting this PR https://github.com/swift-server/swift-aws-lambda-runtime/pull/532 It provides a Streaming+Codable handler that conveniently allows developers to write handlers with `Codable` events for streaming functions. This is a mistake for three reasons: - This is the only handler that assumes a Lamba Event structure as input. I added a minimal `FunctionUrlRequest` and `FunctionURLResponse` to avoid importing the AWS Lambda Events library. It is the first handler to be event-specific. I don't think the runtime should introduce event specific code. - The handler only works when Lambda functions are exposed through Function URLs. Streaming functions can also be invoke by API or CLI. - The handler hides `FunctionURLRequest` details (HTTP headers, query parameters, etc.) from developers Developers were unaware they were trading flexibility for convenience The lack of clear documentation about these limitations led to incorrect usage patterns and frustrated developers who needed full request control or were using other invocation methods. **Modifications:** - Removed the Streaming+Codable API from the library - Moved the Streaming+Codable code to an example - Added prominent warning section in the example README explaining the limitations - Clarified when to use Streaming+Codable vs ByteBuffer approaches - Added decision rule framework to help developers choose the right approach **Result:** The only API provided by the library to use Streaming Lambda functions is exposing the raw `ByteBuffer` as input, there is no more `Codable` handler for Streaming functions available in the API. I kept the `Streaming+Codable` code an example. After this change, developers have clear guidance on when to use each streaming approach: - Use streaming codable for Function URL + JSON payload + no request details needed - Use ByteBuffer StreamingLambdaHandler for full control, other invocation methods, or request metadata access This prevents misuse of the API and sets proper expectations about the handler's capabilities and limitations, leading to better developer experience and fewer integration issues.
Streaming Codable Lambda function
This example demonstrates how to use a StreamingLambdaHandlerWithEvent protocol to create Lambda functions, exposed through a FunctionUrl, that:
- Receive JSON input: Automatically decode JSON events into Swift structs
- Stream responses: Send data incrementally as it becomes available
- Execute background work: Perform additional processing after the response is sent
When to Use This Approach
⚠️ Important Limitations:
- Function URL Only: This streaming codable approach only works with Lambda functions exposed through Lambda Function URLs
- Limited Request Access: This approach hides the details of the
FunctionURLRequest(like HTTP headers, query parameters, etc.) from developers
Decision Rule:
-
Use this streaming codable approach when:
- Your function is exposed through a Lambda Function URL
- You have a JSON payload that you want automatically decoded
- You don't need to inspect HTTP headers, query parameters, or other request details
- You prioritize convenience over flexibility
-
Use the ByteBuffer
StreamingLambdaHandlerapproach when:- You need full control over the
FunctionURLRequestdetails - You're invoking the Lambda through other means (API Gateway, direct invocation, etc.)
- You need access to HTTP headers, query parameters, or request metadata
- You require maximum flexibility (requires writing more code)
- You need full control over the
This example balances convenience and flexibility. The streaming codable interface combines the benefits of:
- Type-safe JSON input decoding (like regular
LambdaHandler) - Response streaming capabilities (like
StreamingLambdaHandler) - Background work execution after response completion
Streaming responses incurs a cost. For more information, see AWS Lambda Pricing.
You can stream responses through Lambda function URLs, the AWS SDK, or using the Lambda InvokeWithResponseStream API.
Code
The sample code creates a StreamingFromEventHandler struct that conforms to the StreamingLambdaHandlerWithEvent protocol provided by the Swift AWS Lambda Runtime.
The handle(...) method of this protocol receives incoming events as a decoded Swift struct (StreamingRequest) and returns the output through a LambdaResponseStreamWriter.
The Lambda function expects a JSON payload with the following structure:
{
"count": 5,
"message": "Hello from streaming Lambda!",
"delayMs": 1000
}
Where:
count: Number of messages to stream (1-100)message: The message content to repeatdelayMs: Optional delay between messages in milliseconds (defaults to 500ms)
The response is streamed through the LambdaResponseStreamWriter, which is passed as an argument in the handle function. The code calls the write(_:) function of the LambdaResponseStreamWriter with partial data written repeatedly before finally closing the response stream by calling finish(). Developers can also choose to return the entire output and not stream the response by calling writeAndFinish(_:).
An error is thrown if finish() is called multiple times or if it is called after having called writeAndFinish(_:).
The handle(...) method is marked as mutating to allow handlers to be implemented with a struct.
Once the struct is created and the handle(...) method is defined, the sample code creates a LambdaRuntime struct and initializes it with the handler just created. Then, the code calls run() to start the interaction with the AWS Lambda control plane.
Key features demonstrated:
- JSON Input Decoding: The function automatically parses the JSON input into a
StreamingRequeststruct - Input Validation: Validates the count parameter and returns an error message if invalid
- Progressive Streaming: Sends messages one by one with configurable delays
- Timestamped Output: Each message includes an ISO8601 timestamp
- Background Processing: Performs cleanup and logging after the response is complete
- Error Handling: Gracefully handles invalid input with descriptive error messages
Build & Package
To build & archive the package, type the following commands.
swift package archive --allow-network-connections docker
If there is no error, there is a ZIP file ready to deploy.
The ZIP file is located at .build/plugins/AWSLambdaPackager/outputs/AWSLambdaPackager/StreamingFromEvent/StreamingFromEvent.zip
Test locally
You can test the function locally before deploying:
swift run
# In another terminal, test with curl:
curl -v \
--header "Content-Type: application/json" \
--data '{"count": 3, "message": "Hello World!", "delayMs": 1000}' \
http://127.0.0.1:7000/invoke
Or simulate a call from a Lambda Function URL (where the body is encapsulated in a Lambda Function URL request):
curl -v \
--header "Content-Type: application/json" \
--data @events/sample-request.json \
http://127.0.0.1:7000/invoke
Deploy with the AWS CLI
Here is how to deploy using the aws command line.
Step 1: Create the function
# Replace with your AWS Account ID
AWS_ACCOUNT_ID=012345678901
aws lambda create-function \
--function-name StreamingFromEvent \
--zip-file fileb://.build/plugins/AWSLambdaPackager/outputs/AWSLambdaPackager/StreamingFromEvent/StreamingFromEvent.zip \
--runtime provided.al2 \
--handler provided \
--architectures arm64 \
--role arn:aws:iam::${AWS_ACCOUNT_ID}:role/lambda_basic_execution
Important
The timeout value must be bigger than the time it takes for your function to stream its output. Otherwise, the Lambda control plane will terminate the execution environment before your code has a chance to finish writing the stream. Here, the sample function stream responses during 10 seconds and we set the timeout for 15 seconds.
The --architectures flag is only required when you build the binary on an Apple Silicon machine (Apple M1 or more recent). It defaults to x64.
Be sure to set AWS_ACCOUNT_ID with your actual AWS account ID (for example: 012345678901).
Step 2: Give permission to invoke that function through a URL
Anyone with a valid signature from your AWS account will have permission to invoke the function through its URL.
aws lambda add-permission \
--function-name StreamingFromEvent \
--action lambda:InvokeFunctionUrl \
--principal ${AWS_ACCOUNT_ID} \
--function-url-auth-type AWS_IAM \
--statement-id allowURL
Step 3: Create the URL
This creates a URL with IAM authentication. Only calls with a valid signature will be authorized.
aws lambda create-function-url-config \
--function-name StreamingFromEvent \
--auth-type AWS_IAM \
--invoke-mode RESPONSE_STREAM
This call returns various information, including the URL to invoke your function.
{
"FunctionUrl": "https://ul3nf4dogmgyr7ffl5r5rs22640fwocc.lambda-url.us-east-1.on.aws/",
"FunctionArn": "arn:aws:lambda:us-east-1:012345678901:function:StreamingFromEvent",
"AuthType": "AWS_IAM",
"CreationTime": "2024-10-22T07:57:23.112599Z",
"InvokeMode": "RESPONSE_STREAM"
}
Invoke your Lambda function
To invoke the Lambda function, use curl with the AWS Sigv4 option to generate the signature.
Read the AWS Credentials and Signature section for more details about the AWS Sigv4 protocol and how to obtain AWS credentials.
When you have the aws command line installed and configured, you will find the credentials in the ~/.aws/credentials file.
URL=https://ul3nf4dogmgyr7ffl5r5rs22640fwocc.lambda-url.us-east-1.on.aws/
REGION=us-east-1
ACCESS_KEY=AK...
SECRET_KEY=...
AWS_SESSION_TOKEN=...
curl --user "${ACCESS_KEY}":"${SECRET_KEY}" \
--aws-sigv4 "aws:amz:${REGION}:lambda" \
-H "x-amz-security-token: ${AWS_SESSION_TOKEN}" \
--no-buffer \
--header "Content-Type: application/json" \
--data '{"count": 3, "message": "Hello World!", "delayMs": 1000}' \
"$URL"
This should output the following result, with configurable delays between each message:
[2024-07-15T05:00:00Z] Message 1/3: Hello World!
[2024-07-15T05:00:01Z] Message 2/3: Hello World!
[2024-07-15T05:00:02Z] Message 3/3: Hello World!
✅ Successfully sent 3 messages
Undeploy
When done testing, you can delete the Lambda function with this command.
aws lambda delete-function --function-name StreamingFromEvent
Deploy with AWS SAM
Alternatively, you can use AWS SAM to deploy the Lambda function.
Prerequisites : Install the SAM CLI
SAM Template
The template file is provided as part of the example in the template.yaml file. It defines a Lambda function based on the binary ZIP file. It creates the function url with IAM authentication and sets the function timeout to 15 seconds.
AWSTemplateFormatVersion: '2010-09-09'
Transform: AWS::Serverless-2016-10-31
Description: SAM Template for StreamingFromEvent Example
Resources:
# Lambda function
StreamingNumbers:
Type: AWS::Serverless::Function
Properties:
CodeUri: .build/plugins/AWSLambdaPackager/outputs/AWSLambdaPackager/StreamingFromEvent/StreamingFromEvent.zip
Timeout: 15
Handler: swift.bootstrap # ignored by the Swift runtime
Runtime: provided.al2
MemorySize: 128
Architectures:
- arm64
FunctionUrlConfig:
AuthType: AWS_IAM
InvokeMode: RESPONSE_STREAM
Outputs:
# print Lambda function URL
LambdaURL:
Description: Lambda URL
Value: !GetAtt StreamingNumbersUrl.FunctionUrl
Deploy with SAM
sam deploy \
--resolve-s3 \
--template-file template.yaml \
--stack-name StreamingFromEvent \
--capabilities CAPABILITY_IAM
The URL of the function is provided as part of the output.
CloudFormation outputs from deployed stack
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Outputs
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Key LambdaURL
Description Lambda URL
Value https://gaudpin2zjqizfujfnqxstnv6u0czrfu.lambda-url.us-east-1.on.aws/
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Once the function is deployed, you can invoke it with curl, similarly to what you did when deploying with the AWS CLI.
curl -X POST \
--data '{"count": 3, "message": "Hello World!", "delayMs": 1000}' \
--user "$ACCESS_KEY":"$SECRET_KEY" \
--aws-sigv4 "aws:amz:${REGION}:lambda" \
-H "x-amz-security-token: $AWS_SESSION_TOKEN" \
--no-buffer \
"$URL"
Undeploy with SAM
When done testing, you can delete the infrastructure with this command.
sam delete