## Summary
The test started to fail after
https://github.com/facebook/react/pull/29088.
Fork the test and the expected store state for:
- React 18.x, to represent the previous behavior
- React >= 19, to represent the current RDT behavior, where error can't
be connected to the fiber, because it was not yet mounted and shared
with DevTools.
Ideally, DevTools should start keeping track of such fibers, but also
distinguish them from some that haven't mounted due to Suspense or error
boundaries.
This is necessary to simplify the component stack handling to make way
for owner stacks. It also solves some hacks that we used to have but
don't quite make sense. It also solves the problem where things like key
warnings get silenced in RSC because they get deduped. It also surfaces
areas where we were missing key warnings to begin with.
Almost every type of warning is issued from the renderer. React Elements
are really not anything special themselves. They're just lazily invoked
functions and its really the renderer that determines there semantics.
We have three types of warnings that previously fired in
JSX/createElement:
- Fragment props validation.
- Type validation.
- Key warning.
It's nice to be able to do some validation in the JSX/createElement
because it has a more specific stack frame at the callsite. However,
that's the case for every type of component and validation. That's the
whole point of enableOwnerStacks. It's also not sufficient to do it in
JSX/createElement so we also have validation in the renderers too. So
this validation is really just an eager validation but also happens
again later.
The problem with these is that we don't really know what types are valid
until we get to the renderer. Additionally, by placing it in the
isomorphic code it becomes harder to do deduping of warnings in a way
that makes sense for that renderer. It also means we can't reuse logic
for managing stacks etc.
Fragment props validation really should just be part of the renderer
like any other component type. This also matters once we add Fragment
refs and other fragment features. So I moved this into Fiber. However,
since some Fragments don't have Fibers, I do the validation in
ChildFiber instead of beginWork where it would normally happen.
For `type` validation we already do validation when rendering. By
leaving it to the renderer we don't have to hard code an extra list.
This list also varies by context. E.g. class components aren't allowed
in RSC but client references are but we don't have an isomorphic way to
identify client references because they're defined by the host config so
the current logic is flawed anyway. I kept the early validation for now
without the `enableOwnerStacks` since it does provide a nicer stack
frame but with that flag on it'll be handled with nice stacks anyway. I
normalized some of the errors to ensure tests pass.
For `key` validation it's the same principle. The mechanism for the
heuristic is still the same - if it passes statically through a parent
JSX/createElement call then it's considered validated. We already did
print the error later from the renderer so this also disables the early
log in the `enableOwnerStacks` flag.
I also added logging to Fizz so that key warnings can print in SSR logs.
Flight is a bit more complex. For elements that end up on the client we
just pass the `validated` flag along to the client and let the client
renderer print the error once rendered. For server components we log the
error from Flight with the server component as the owner on the stack
which will allow us to print the right stack for context. The factoring
of this is a little tricky because we only want to warn if it's in an
array parent but we want to log the error later to get the right debug
info.
Fiber/Fizz has a similar factoring problem that causes us to create a
fake Fiber for the owner which means the logs won't be associated with
the right place in DevTools.
Adds a flag to disable legacy mode. Currently this flag is used to cause
legacy mode apis like render and hydrate to throw. This change also
removes render, hydrate, unmountComponentAtNode, and
unstable_renderSubtreeIntoContainer from the experiemntal entrypoint.
Right now for Meta builds this flag is off (legacy mode is still
supported). In OSS builds this flag matches __NEXT_MAJOR__ which means
it currently is on in experiemental. This means that after merging
legacy mode is effectively removed from experimental builds. While this
is a breaking change, experimental builds are not stable and users can
pin to older versions or update their use of react-dom to no longer use
legacy mode APIs.
## Summary
as we began [discussing
yesterday](https://github.com/facebook/react/pull/27056#discussion_r1253282784),
`SuspenseList` is not actually stable yet, and should likely be exported
with the `unstable_` prefix.
the conversation yesterday began discussing this in the context of the
fb-specific packages, but changing it there without updating everywhere
else leads to test failures, so here the change is made across packages.
## How did you test this change?
```
yarn flow dom-browser
yarn test
```
The old version of prettier we were using didn't support the Flow syntax
to access properties in a type using `SomeType['prop']`. This updates
`prettier` and `rollup-plugin-prettier` to the latest versions.
I added the prettier config `arrowParens: "avoid"` to reduce the diff
size as the default has changed in Prettier 2.0. The largest amount of
changes comes from function expressions now having a space. This doesn't
have an option to preserve the old behavior, so we have to update this.
* Facebook -> Meta in copyright
rg --files | xargs sed -i 's#Copyright (c) Facebook, Inc. and its affiliates.#Copyright (c) Meta Platforms, Inc. and affiliates.#g'
* Manual tweaks
We've recently had multiple reports where, if React DevTools was installed, unmounting large React subtrees would take a huge performance hit (ex. from 50ms to 7 seconds).
Digging in more, we realized for every fiber that unmounts, we called `untrackFibers`, which calls `clearTimeout` (and does some work manipulating a set, but this wasn't the bulk of the time). We ten call `recordUnmount`, which adds the timer back. Adding and removing the timer so many times was taking upwards of 50ms per timer add/remove call, which was resulting in exorbitant amounts of time spent in DevTools deleting subtrees.
It looks like we are calling `untrackFibers` so many times to avoid a race condition with Suspense children where we unmount them twice (first a "virtual" unmount when the suspense boundary is toggled from visible to invisible, and then an actual unmount when the new children are rendered) without modifying `fiberIDMap`. We can fix this race condition by using the `untrackFibersSet` as a lock and not calling `recordUnmount` if the fiber is in the set and hasn't been processed yet. This works because the only way fibers are added in the set is via `recordUnmount` anyway.
This PR also adds a test to make sure this change doesn't regress the previous behavior.
**Before**
**After**
This PR adds the reactVersion pragma to tests.
Tests without the reactVersion pragma won't be run if the reactVersion pragma isn't specified.
Tested each React version manually with the pragma to make sure the tests pass
* Move createRoot/hydrateRoot to /client
We want these APIs ideally to be imported separately from things you
might use in arbitrary components (like flushSync). Those other methods
are "isomorphic" to how the ReactDOM tree is rendered. Similar to hooks.
E.g. importing flushSync into a component that only uses it on the client
should ideally not also pull in the entry client implementation on the
server.
This also creates a nicer parity with /server where the roots are in a
separate entry point.
Unfortunately, I can't quite do this yet because we have some legacy APIs
that we plan on removing (like findDOMNode) and we also haven't implemented
flushSync using a flag like startTransition does yet.
Another problem is that we currently encourage these APIs to be aliased by
/profiling (or unstable_testing). In the future you don't have to alias
them because you can just change your roots to just import those APIs and
they'll still work with the isomorphic forms. Although we might also just
use export conditions for them.
For that all to work, I went with a different strategy for now where the
real API is in / but it comes with a warning if you use it. If you instead
import /client it disables the warning in a wrapper. That means that if you
alias / then import /client that will inturn import the alias and it'll
just work.
In a future breaking changes (likely when we switch to ESM) we can just
remove createRoot/hydrateRoot from / and move away from the aliasing
strategy.
* Update tests to import from react-dom/client
* Fix fixtures
* Update warnings
* Add test for the warning
* Update devtools
* Change order of react-dom, react-dom/client alias
I think the order matters here. The first one takes precedence.
* Require react-dom through client so it can be aliased
Co-authored-by: Andrew Clark <git@andrewclark.io>
Refactor DevTools to record Timeline data (in memory) while profiling. Updated the Profiler UI to import/export Timeline data along with legacy profiler data.
Relates to issue #22529
Adds the concept of subtree modes to DevTools to bridge protocol as follows:
1. Add-root messages get two new attributes: one specifying whether the root is running in strict mode and another specifying whether the root (really the root's renderer) supports the concept of strict mode.
2. A new backend message type (TREE_OPERATION_SET_SUBTREE_MODE). This type specifies a subtree root (id) and a mode (bitmask). For now, the only mode this message deals with is strict mode.
The DevTools frontend has been updated as well to highlight non-StrictMode compliant components.
The changes to the bridge protocol require incrementing the bridge protocol version number, which will also require updating the version of react-devtools-core backend that is shipped with React Native.
Changes our text encoding approach to properly support multibyte characters following this algorithm. Based on benchmarking, this new approach is roughly equivalent in terms of performance (sometimes slightly faster, sometimes slightly slower).
I also considered using TextEncoder/TextDecoder for this, but it was much slower (~85%).
The following APIs have been added to the `react` stable entry point:
* `SuspenseList`
* `startTransition`
* `unstable_createMutableSource`
* `unstable_useMutableSource`
* `useDeferredValue`
* `useTransition`
The following APIs have been added or removed from the `react-dom` stable entry point:
* `createRoot`
* `unstable_createPortal` (removed)
The following APIs have been added to the `react-is` stable entry point:
* `SuspenseList`
* `isSuspenseList`
The following feature flags have been changed from experimental to true:
* `enableLazyElements`
* `enableSelectiveHydration`
* `enableSuspenseServerRenderer`
* DevTools flushes updated passive warning/error info after delay
Previously this information was not flushed until the next commit, but this provides a worse user experience if the next commit is really delayed. Instead, the backend now flushes only the warning/error counts after a delay. As a safety, if there are already any pending operations in the queue, we bail.
Co-authored-by: eps1lon <silbermann.sebastian@gmail.com>
DevTools was built with a fork of an early idea for how Suspense cache might work. This idea is incompatible with newer APIs like `useTransition` which unfortunately prevented me from making certain UX improvements. This PR swaps out the primary usage of this cache (there are a few) in favor of the newer `unstable_getCacheForType` and `unstable_useCacheRefresh` APIs. We can go back and update the others in follow up PRs.
### Messaging changes
I've refactored the way the frontend loads component props/state/etc to hopefully make it better match the Suspense+cache model. Doing this gave up some of the small optimizations I'd added but hopefully the actual performance impact of that is minor and the overall ergonomic improvements of working with the cache API make this worth it.
The backend no longer remembers inspected paths. Instead, the frontend sends them every time and the backend sends a response with those paths. I've also added a new "force" parameter that the frontend can use to tell the backend to send a response even if the component hasn't rendered since the last time it asked. (This is used to get data for newly inspected paths.)
_Initial inspection..._
```
front | | back
| -- "inspect" (id:1, paths:[], force:true) ---------> |
| <------------------------ "inspected" (full-data) -- |
```
_1 second passes with no updates..._
```
| -- "inspect" (id:1, paths:[], force:false) --------> |
| <------------------------ "inspected" (no-change) -- |
```
_User clicks to expand a path, aka hydrate..._
```
| -- "inspect" (id:1, paths:['foo'], force:true) ----> |
| <------------------------ "inspected" (full-data) -- |
```
_1 second passes during which there is an update..._
```
| -- "inspect" (id:1, paths:['foo'], force:false) ---> |
| <----------------- "inspectedElement" (full-data) -- |
```
### Clear errors/warnings transition
Previously this meant there would be a delay after clicking the "clear" button. The UX after this change is much improved.
### Hydrating paths transition
I also added a transition to hydration (expanding "dehyrated" paths).
### Better error boundaries
I also added a lower-level error boundary in case the new suspense operation ever failed. It provides a better "retry" mechanism (select a new element) so DevTools doesn't become entirely useful. Here I'm intentionally causing an error every time I select an element.
### Improved snapshot tests
I also migrated several of the existing snapshot tests to use inline snapshots and added a new serializer for dehydrated props. Inline snapshots are easier to verify and maintain and the new serializer means dehydrated props will be formatted in a way that makes sense rather than being empty (in external snapshots) or super verbose (default inline snapshot format).
DevTools has a feature to force a Suspense boundary to show a fallback.
This feature causes us to skip the first render pass (where we render
the primary children) and go straight to rendering the fallback.
There's a Legacy Mode-only codepath that failed to take this scenario
into account, instead assuming that whenever a fallback is being
rendered, it was preceded by an attempt to render the primary children.
SuspenseList can also cause us to skip the first pass, but the relevant
branch is Legacy Mode-only, and SuspenseList is not supported in
Legacy Mode.
Fixes a test that I had temporarily disabled when upstreaming the Lanes
implementation in #19108.
* Add autofix to cross-fork lint rule
* replace-fork: Replaces old fork contents with new
For each file in the new fork, copies the contents into the
corresponding file of the old fork, replacing what was already there.
In contrast to merge-fork, which performs a three-way merge.
* Replace old fork contents with new fork
First I ran `yarn replace-fork`.
Then I ran `yarn lint` with autofix enabled. There's currently no way to
do that from the command line (we should fix that), so I had to edit the
lint script file.
* Manual fix-ups
Removes dead branches, removes prefixes from internal fields. Stuff
like that.
* Fix DevTools tests
DevTools tests only run against the old fork, which is why I didn't
catch these earlier.
There is one test that is still failing. I'm fairly certain it's related
to the layout of the Suspense fiber: we no longer conditionally wrap the
primary children. They are always wrapped in an extra fiber.
Since this has been running in www for weeks without major issues, I'll
defer fixing the remaining test to a follow up.
We've been shipping unprefixed experimental APIs (like `createRoot` and
`useTransition`) to the Experimental release channel, with the rationale
that because these APIs do not appear in any stable release, we're free
to change or remove them later without breaking any downstream projects.
What we didn't consider is that downstream projects might be tempted to
use feature detection:
```js
const useTransition = React.useTransition || fallbackUseTransition;
```
This pattern assumes that the version of `useTransition` that exists in
the Experimental channel today has the same API contract as the final
`useTransition` API that we'll eventually ship to stable.
To discourage feature detection, I've added an `unstable_` prefix to
all of our unstable APIs.
The Facebook builds still have the unprefixed APIs, though. We will
continue to support those; if we make any breaking changes, we'll
migrate the internal callers like we usually do. To make testing easier,
I added the `unstable_`-prefixed APIs to the www builds, too. That way
our tests can always use the prefixed ones without gating on the
release channel.
* Add feature flag
* Split stack from current fiber
You can get stack from any fiber, not just current.
* Refactor description of component frames
These should use fiber tags for switching. This also puts the relevant code
behind DEV flags.
* We no longer expose StrictMode in component stacks
They're not super useful and will go away later anyway.
* Update tests
Context is no longer part of SSR stacks. This was already the case on the
client.
forwardRef no longer is wrapped on the stack. It's still in getComponentName
but it's probably just noise in stacks. Eventually we'll remove the wrapper
so it'll go away anyway. If we use native stack frames they won't have this
extra wrapper.
It also doesn't pick up displayName from the outer wrapper. We could maybe
transfer it but this will also be fixed by removing the wrapper.
* Forward displayName onto the inner function for forwardRef and memo in DEV
This allows them to show up in stack traces.
I'm not doing this for lazy because lazy is supposed to be called on the
consuming side so you shouldn't assign it a name on that end. Especially
not one that mutates the inner.
* Use multiple instances of the fake component
We mutate the inner component for its name so we need multiple copies.
1. Add a Store test for memo, lazy, and forwardRef components
2. Remove dead code for React.lazy
3. Update DT tests to include HOC badge names in the serialized store
* SuspenseList support in DevTools
This adds SuspenseList tags to DevTools so that the name properly shows
up.
It also switches to use the tag instead of Symbol type for Suspense
components. We shouldn't rely on the type for any built-ins since that
field will disappear from the fibers. How the Fibers get created is an
implementation detail that can change e.g. with a compiler or if we
use instanceof checks that are faster than symbol comparisons.
* Add SuspenseList test to shell app
Ruslan Lesiutin
Sebastian Markbåge
Joseph Savona
Josh Story
Noah Lemen
Jan Kassens
Andrew Clark
Sebastian Silbermann
Luna Ruan
Brian Vaughn
Ricky
Nick Reiley
Sebastian Markbåge
